Student Loan Payoff Guide: Where Your Loans Fit in a Debt Plan
How to fit student loans into a debt payoff plan: federal vs private loans, what to pay first, when extra payments make sense and how to see your payoff date.
Terry ThreattLast updated · 2 min readTL;DR
Put every student loan in your payoff plan, listed separately with its own rate. Pay credit cards and private loans before federal loans, and be careful sending extra to federal loans if you rely on income-driven repayment or expect forgiveness.
Track your own plan in Toffee:

Student Loans Are Not All the Same
The most important thing to know about your student loans is which ones are federal and which are private. Federal loans come with options private loans do not have: repayment plans based on your income, deferment and forbearance when money is tight, and forgiveness programs for some careers. Private loans work like any other installment loan.
Your federal loans are listed in your account at studentaid.gov. Anything that is not there is private.
Where Student Loans Go in Your Payoff Order
- Credit cards and other high-rate debt first. Card rates are usually several times higher than student loan rates.
- Private student loans next, highest rate first. They have the fewest safety nets.
- Federal student loans last, unless their rate is higher than your other debts.
With a typical mix of a card, a private loan and a federal loan, the snowball and the avalanche often agree on this order. We ran the numbers in should student loans be in your debt snowball?: including them saved about $4,030 in interest and five years compared with leaving them on their own schedule.
See your debt-free date
Toffee builds your snowball or avalanche plan and shows exactly when you'll be debt-free. No bank login required. On iOS & Android.
When Extra Payments Make Sense
Extra payments always make sense on private loans. On federal loans, check two things first: whether you expect a forgiveness program to cancel part of the balance, and whether your payment is set by an income-driven plan. In either case, extra payments may not save you what you expect. Get a small emergency fund and any employer 401(k) match in place first too; should you save or pay off debt first? lays out the order.
When you do pay extra, ask your servicer to apply it to principal on the loan you are targeting, so it does not just push your next due date back.
See Your Student Loan Payoff Date
List each loan with its balance, rate and minimum in the debt payoff calculator to see when you will be done, or read how to know the month you'll be debt-free to do it by hand. To track your loans alongside your other debts, see Toffee for student loan debt.
Every guide on student loans
- How to Make Extra Student Loan Payments Go to Principal
How to make extra payments on student loans go to principal, not a future due date: what paid ahead status is, what to tell your servicer and how to check.
- How to Pay Off Grad School Debt: Payoff vs. Forgiveness Paths
How to pay off grad school debt: Grad PLUS vs unsubsidized loans, when to pay aggressively, when an income-driven or forgiveness path fits, with real numbers.
- How to Pay Off Private Student Loans Fast: A Step-by-Step Plan
How to pay off private student loans fast: list each loan, target the highest rate, send extra to principal and know when refinancing helps. With real numbers.
- Pay Off Credit Cards or Student Loans First? A Rate-by-Rate Guide
Should you pay off credit cards or student loans first? Compare rates side by side, see the exceptions (0% cards, pricey private loans, forgiveness) and math.
- Should Student Loans Be in Your Debt Snowball?
Should student loans go in your debt snowball or avalanche? When to include them, when to leave federal loans on minimums, and what it costs, with real numbers.
- Student Loan Payoff Date: How to Find Yours and Move It Up
Find your student loan payoff date for each loan and overall, see how extra payments move it, and check a worked example with three loans and real numbers.
Free tools and pages for this topic
Frequently asked questions
Should I pay off student loans or credit cards first?
Credit cards first in almost every case. They charge much higher interest and have none of the protections federal student loans offer.
Is it better to pay off private or federal student loans first?
Private loans first, especially when their rate is higher. Federal loans offer income-driven repayment, deferment and forgiveness options that private loans do not.
Is there a penalty for paying off student loans early?
No. Federal student loans have no prepayment penalty, and private student lenders cannot charge one either.
Sources
Ready to crush your debt?
Toffee shows your exact debt-free date with the snowball or avalanche method. No bank login required. On iOS & Android.

Terry Threatt, Founder of Toffee
Terry Threatt founded Toffee Finance Inc. and designs and builds Toffee, the debt payoff planner for iPhone and Android, from the payoff engine to the Apple Watch app.
Related posts
- How to Pay Off Grad School Debt: Payoff vs. Forgiveness Paths
How to pay off grad school debt: Grad PLUS vs unsubsidized loans, when to pay aggressively, when an income-driven or forgiveness path fits, with real numbers.
- Pay Off Credit Cards or Student Loans First? A Rate-by-Rate Guide
Should you pay off credit cards or student loans first? Compare rates side by side, see the exceptions (0% cards, pricey private loans, forgiveness) and math.
- How to Pay Off Private Student Loans Fast: A Step-by-Step Plan
How to pay off private student loans fast: list each loan, target the highest rate, send extra to principal and know when refinancing helps. With real numbers.
- Student Loan Payoff Date: How to Find Yours and Move It Up
Find your student loan payoff date for each loan and overall, see how extra payments move it, and check a worked example with three loans and real numbers.
The content in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Payoff dates and interest figures are estimates based on the assumptions stated in the article.