Student loans

Should Student Loans Be in Your Debt Snowball?

Should student loans go in your debt snowball or avalanche? When to include them, when to leave federal loans on minimums, and what it costs, with real numbers.

By Last updated · 4 min read

TL;DR

Yes, for most people: list student loans in your debt snowball or avalanche, but they usually land last because their rates and balances are lower than credit cards. Leave federal loans on minimums only if you rely on income-driven repayment or forgiveness, or if their rate is low enough that you would rather invest.

Track your own plan in Toffee:

Part of our guide to student loans.

Person at a desk planning how student loans fit into a debt payoff plan

The Short Answer

Student loans belong in your payoff plan. Leaving them off the list does not make them cheaper; it just means you stop looking at them. The real question is not whether to include them, it is where they land in the order and whether you send them any extra money.

In most plans they land at the end. Credit cards charge far more interest and usually have smaller balances, so both the debt avalanche and the debt snowball put the cards first. By the time your extra money reaches the student loans, you are rolling over every payment you freed up on the way.

Where Student Loans Usually Land in the Order

Take a common mix: a credit card, a private student loan and a larger federal loan.

DebtBalanceAPRMinimum
Credit card$4,00022%$120
Private student loan$6,0009%$76
Federal student loan$18,0005.5%$195

Here the snowball (smallest balance first) and the avalanche (highest rate first) pick the same order: card, private loan, federal loan. That happens a lot with student loans, because the biggest balance often carries the lowest rate. If your list looks like this, you can skip the snowball versus avalanche debate entirely.

What Including Them Saves, With Real Numbers

We ran the debts above through the same payoff engine behind our debt payoff calculator, with $150 a month on top of the $391 in minimums, starting November 2026.

PlanDebt-freeTotal interest
Student loans in the snowball (extra rolls into them)January 2032$5,258
Card only; student loans left on their own minimumsDecember 2036$9,288

With the loans in the plan, the card is gone in May 2028, the private loan in October 2029 and the federal loan in January 2032. Leave the loans out and the card still goes in May 2028, but the loans keep running on their original schedule for almost another five years. Including them saves about $4,030 in interest and five years.

To be fair to the other side: in the second plan, the $270 a month that cleared the card is freed up from mid 2028, so it can go to savings or investing instead. That trade-off is the whole decision, and the next section is about when it tips the other way.

When to Leave Federal Loans on Minimums

Keep federal loans in your plan so you can see them, but think twice before sending them extra money if any of these apply:

  • You are working toward forgiveness. If you expect a forgiveness program such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness to cancel the balance, extra payments can simply shrink the amount that would have been forgiven. Check your eligibility at studentaid.gov.
  • Your payment depends on your income. On an income-driven plan, your required payment is set by what you earn. Paying extra still lowers the balance, but run the numbers first, because the plan itself may cost you less over time.
  • You have no emergency fund yet. A small cash cushion comes before extra debt payments of any kind. Our guide on saving versus paying off debt lays out the order.
  • The rate is low and you are investing. At around 4% to 6%, paying extra on a federal loan is a solid guaranteed return, but taking an employer 401(k) match first almost always wins.

None of these apply to private student loans, which have no forgiveness or income-based payments. Treat a private loan like any other installment loan and give it extra money in rate order.

How to Add Student Loans to Your Plan

  1. List each loan separately. Your servicer shows every loan in a group with its own balance and rate. Separate loans let the plan target the most expensive one first.
  2. Use the real rate and the real minimum. Take both from your servicer account, not from memory.
  3. Pick your method. Snowball if you need early wins, avalanche to pay the least interest. See which debt to pay off first if you are unsure.
  4. Tell the servicer where extra money goes. When you pay extra on a student loan, ask the servicer to apply it to principal on a specific loan. Otherwise it may be used to push your next due date back instead.
  5. Check your debt-free date every month. Seeing the date move is what keeps a five-year plan alive. Here is how to work out your debt-free date.

See your debt-free date

Toffee builds your snowball or avalanche plan and shows exactly when you'll be debt-free. No bank login required. On iOS & Android.

Frequently asked questions

Should I pay off credit cards or student loans first?

Credit cards first in almost every case. Card rates are usually two to four times higher than student loan rates, cards have no fixed end date, and they offer none of the protections federal loans do.

Is the debt snowball good for student loans?

Yes. Listing each student loan separately and paying them in snowball order works well, and with several loans the early payoffs come quickly. If your loans have very different rates, the avalanche will save more interest.

Can I pay extra on student loans without a penalty?

Yes. Federal student loans have no prepayment penalty, and private student lenders cannot charge one either. Ask your servicer to apply the extra to principal on the loan you are targeting.

Should I refinance federal student loans to pay them off faster?

Only after careful thought. Refinancing federal loans into a private loan can lower the rate, but you permanently give up federal options such as income-driven repayment, deferment and forgiveness programs.

Keep reading

Sources

  1. Federal Student Aid: Repayment plans
  2. Federal Student Aid: Public Service Loan Forgiveness
  3. CFPB: Can I make additional payments on my student loan?

Put your student loans in the plan

Add each loan and card to Toffee, pick snowball or avalanche, and see the month you will be debt-free. No bank login. On iOS and Android.

Avatar of Terry Threatt

, Founder of Toffee

Terry Threatt founded Toffee Finance Inc. and designs and builds Toffee, the debt payoff planner for iPhone and Android, from the payoff engine to the Apple Watch app.

More from Terry Threatt · Contact

Related posts

See every guide on student loans

The content in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Payoff dates and interest figures are estimates based on the assumptions stated in the article.