Debt payoff apps and tools

Tally App Alternatives: What to Use Now That Tally Shut Down

Tally, the credit card payoff app, shut down in August 2024. The best Tally alternatives for planning card payoff, plus options that replace its lower rate.

By Last updated · 5 min read

TL;DR

Tally shut down in August 2024, and no app now pays your cards for you with a lower-rate credit line. The practical replacement is a payoff planner like Toffee (our app) or Debt Payoff Planner to order your cards, plus a balance transfer, consolidation loan or credit counselor if you want Tally's lower rate.

Track your own plan in Toffee:

Part of our guide to debt payoff apps and tools.

Several credit cards next to a phone showing a credit card payoff plan, representing alternatives to the Tally app

What Happened to Tally

Tally was a San Francisco fintech that helped people pay down high-interest credit card balances with a lower-interest line of credit. In April 2024 it said it would close its consumer app and move to business software. Then, on August 12, 2024, its founder announced that the company was shutting down after failing to raise the funding it needed.

If you still owe money from a Tally line of credit, follow the most recent repayment instructions you were sent and keep paying on time. The rest of this post is about the cards themselves: how to keep paying them down without Tally.

What Tally Did, and What Replaces Each Part

It helps to split what Tally did into parts, because no single product today does all of them.

What Tally didWhat replaces it now
Organized your cards and decided where money wentA debt payoff planner using the avalanche (highest rate first) or snowball method
Swapped card interest for a lower-rate credit lineA 0% balance transfer card, a debt consolidation loan or a nonprofit debt management plan
Made payments on time automaticallyAutopay set up with each card issuer, plus reminders before due dates

Most former Tally users need the first and third rows. The second row only helps if you can actually qualify for a lower rate, and it is worth doing carefully. Our Tally alternatives page has a quick side-by-side if you just want the summary.

Payoff Planners That Replace Tally's Organizing

1. Toffee: Best for Planning Credit Card Payoff

Toffee is the app we build. Tally's core idea was paying the most expensive card first, which is exactly the avalanche method, and Toffee runs it (or the snowball, if you prefer quick wins). You add your cards yourself, and Toffee shows which card to pay next, your debt-free month and the interest you save. Push and email reminders arrive before every due date.

Unlike Tally, Toffee does not lend money or move it, and it never asks for a bank login. It also tracks student loans, personal loans, payday loans and buy now, pay later plans, so it can hold your whole picture, not just cards. It is on iPhone and Android, free to download, with Toffee Pro unlocked in the app; current plans are shown there.

2. Debt Payoff Planner: Best Low-Cost App

Debt Payoff Planner by OxbowSoft builds an avalanche or snowball schedule from balances you enter, on iPhone and Android, with a free version that shows ads. It has no bill reminders, so lean on autopay with your issuers. Read Toffee vs. Debt Payoff Planner for the details.

3. Undebt.it: Best Free Web Planner

Undebt.it is a free browser-based planner with many payoff orders and detailed control. Its paid Undebt.it+ tier adds features such as bill tracking and optional bank sync. It is the better choice if you like working on a computer. See Toffee vs. Undebt.it.

4. A Spreadsheet: Best if You Want Full Control

Our free debt snowball spreadsheet works in Google Sheets or Excel and switches to the avalanche with one dropdown. It will not remind you of due dates, so set calendar alerts.

See your debt-free date

Toffee builds your snowball or avalanche plan and shows exactly when you'll be debt-free. No bank login required. On iOS & Android.

Options That Replace Tally's Lower Rate

These are not apps, but they are the closest thing to what Tally's credit line did: move card balances to a cheaper rate. Each comes with catches, so read the terms.

  • 0% balance transfer card. Moves balances to a card with a temporary low or zero rate. There is usually a transfer fee, the rate rises when the promotion ends, and new purchases may be charged interest right away. Plan to clear the balance before the promo runs out.
  • Debt consolidation loan. Combines cards into one fixed payment, often from a bank or credit union. A lower payment can come from a longer term, which may cost more in total, so compare total interest, not just the monthly amount.
  • Nonprofit credit counseling. A counselor can review your budget and may set up a debt management plan with your card issuers. Be wary of companies that charge large up-front fees or tell you to stop paying your debts.

Your First Week Without Tally

  1. List every card with its balance, APR and minimum, taken from your latest statements.
  2. Turn on autopay for at least the minimum on each card, directly with the issuer.
  3. Pick a method. Avalanche mirrors Tally's highest-rate-first logic; snowball gives faster early wins. Our guide to paying off credit card debt explains both.
  4. Decide your extra amount each month and send it all to the top card on your list.
  5. Ask for a lower rate. A short call to each issuer sometimes works; use our script to ask for a lower APR.

For more on choosing tools, see our guide to debt payoff apps and tools.

Frequently asked questions

When did Tally shut down?

Tally's founder announced the shutdown on August 12, 2024, saying the company could not raise the funding it needed. Earlier, in April 2024, Tally had said it would close its consumer app and move to business software.

Is there another app that pays off your credit cards like Tally did?

Not one we know of. Tally's model combined a lower-rate credit line with automatic payments. Today the closest equivalent is a balance transfer card or consolidation loan for the rate, plus a payoff planner and autopay for the organizing.

What is the best Tally alternative?

For organizing card payoff, Toffee (our app) is a strong fit: it runs the avalanche or snowball method, shows which card to pay next and your debt-free month, and reminds you before due dates. Debt Payoff Planner is a good low-cost option, and Undebt.it is a capable free web tool.

I still owe money on a Tally line of credit. What should I do?

Keep paying it on time, following the latest repayment instructions you received. Add it to your payoff plan as its own debt so it is ordered alongside your cards.

Keep reading

Sources

  1. TechCrunch: a16z-backed fintech Tally, which raised $172M in funding, is shutting down after running out of cash (August 12, 2024)
  2. Banking Dive: Fintech Tally closes over failure to raise capital
  3. CFPB: What is a debt consolidation loan?
  4. CFPB: What is credit counseling?
  5. Undebt.it: free plan and Undebt.it+ features
  6. Google Play: Debt Payoff Planner & Tracker (OxbowSoft)

Replace Tally's plan in a few minutes

Add your cards to Toffee, choose avalanche or snowball, and see which card to pay next and when you will be debt-free. No bank login.

Avatar of Terry Threatt

, Founder of Toffee

Terry Threatt founded Toffee Finance Inc. and designs and builds Toffee, the debt payoff planner for iPhone and Android, from the payoff engine to the Apple Watch app.

More from Terry Threatt · Contact

Related posts

See every guide on debt payoff apps and tools

The content in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Payoff dates and interest figures are estimates based on the assumptions stated in the article.